Curated Decay

Heritage beyond Saving

2017
Author:

Caitlin DeSilvey

A bold new approach to heritage conservation that embraces change and accommodates decay

Transporting readers from derelict homesteads to Cold War test sites, Curated Decay presents an unparalleled provocation to conventional thinking on the conservation of cultural heritage. Caitlin DeSilvey proposes rethinking the care of certain vulnerable sites in terms of ecology and entropy, explaining how we must adopt an ethical stance that allows us to collaborate with—rather than defend against—natural processes.

Curated Decay offers a sophisticated and novel account of sites that challenge the current paradigm of conservation. It also proposes a wealth of concepts by which the curation of such sites may be rethought in terms of ecological culture. The writing is fresh, direct and exciting and carries the reader along effortlessly.

Amanda Boetzkes, University of Guelph

Transporting readers from derelict homesteads to imperiled harbors, postindustrial ruins to Cold War test sites, Curated Decay presents an unparalleled provocation to conventional thinking on the conservation of cultural heritage. Caitlin DeSilvey proposes rethinking the care of certain vulnerable sites in terms of ecology and entropy, and explains how we must adopt an ethical stance that allows us to collaborate with—rather than defend against—natural processes.

Curated Decay chronicles DeSilvey’s travels to places where experiments in curated ruination and creative collapse are under way, or under consideration. It uses case studies from the United States, Europe, and elsewhere to explore how objects and structures produce meaning not only in their preservation and persistence, but also in their decay and disintegration. Through accessible and engaging discussion of specific places and their stories, it traces how cultural memory is generated in encounters with ephemeral artifacts and architectures.

An interdisciplinary reframing of the concept of the ruin that combines historical and philosophical depth with attentive storytelling, Curated Decay represents the first attempt to apply new theories of materiality and ecology to the concerns of critical heritage studies.

Awards

Historic Preservation Book Prize from the Center for Historic Preservation

Caitlin DeSilvey is associate professor of cultural geography at the University of Exeter. She is coauthor of Visible Mending and coeditor of Anticipatory History.


Curated Decay offers a sophisticated and novel account of sites that challenge the current paradigm of conservation. It also proposes a wealth of concepts by which the curation of such sites may be rethought in terms of ecological culture. The writing is fresh, direct and exciting and carries the reader along effortlessly.

Amanda Boetzkes, University of Guelph

Curated Decay is wondrously marvelous—a brilliant and beautiful exploration of how we can and might engage with the ultimately evanescent companions (landscapes, buildings, objects) that accompany our own evanescent lives. Caitlin DeSilvey sets her deeply thoughtful meditations on our ambivalent interactions with the transient things we cherish in evocative discourses about a dozen hauntingly depicted diverse threatened and beleaguered locales, from Montana to Cornwall to Scotland and the Ruhr. These illustrative stories are couched in a narrative of personal travel and discovery that is a continual joy to read, fresh, witty, and jargon-free.

David Lowenthal, University College London

You get the sense quite quickly that it would be fascinating to spend a morning with Caitlin DeSilvey going through a neglected industrial building or some other ostensibly uninteresting structure on the verge of collapse.

The Journal of Wild Culture

In the experimental heritage policy defended by DeSilvey, decay and entropy are not synonymous of destruction and loss, they open instead the possibility of seeing loss and destruction as the beginning of something new, not only in the material sense of the word but also in the cultural sense of the word, provided people manage to develop new ways of living the permanent change of things in relationship with their own transience and mortality. Curated Decay is an essential contribution to a debate that we can no longer avoid.

Leonardo Reviews

It is a beautiful read that will vibrate with afterthoughts.

AAG Review of Books

Curated Decay is a thought-provoking work by an innovative heritage scholar who urges acceptance of the reality that material heritage is subject to increasingly serious threats in the Anthropocene.

Traditional Dwellings and Settlements Review

Caitlin DeSilvey’s Curated Decay: Heritage beyond Saving asks readers to consider possibilities for ‘preservation’ that embrace the decay and decomposition of human-made things. Drawing on personal experiences over many years in both


the United States and the United Kingdom, DeSilvey attempts to conceive of a preservation paradigm that considers decay not as loss but as an equally productive means to understanding human cultural heritage.

Historical Geography

A must-read for scholars coming to grips with the new materialism in the fields of geography and critical heritage studies.

Journal of Historical Geography

Contents


1. Postpreservation: Looking Past Loss


2. Memory’s Ecologies: Curating Mutability in Montana


3. When Story Meets the Storm: Unsafe Harbor


4. Orderly Decay: Philosophies of Nonintervention


5. A Positive Passivity: Entropic Gardens


6. Boundary Work: On Expertise and Ambiguity


7. Palliative Curation: The Death of a Lighthouse


8. Beyond Saving: Care without Conservation


Acknowledgments


Notes


Permissions


Index


Heritage Futures, an interdisciplinary research program exploring the potential for innovation and creative exchange in heritage practice.

 

Video recording of a book panel discussion exploring the themes of Curated Decay with the author, Professor David Lowenthal (Emeritus Professor of Geography, UCL), Haidy Geismar (Reader in Digital Anthropology, UCL), and Professor Rodney Harrison (Professor of Heritage Studies, UCL), held at University College London on 22 June 2017.

BBC Radio 4 Thinking Allowed podcast of Laurie Taylor talking to Caitlin DeSilvey about the ideas in Curated Decay. Originally broadcast on 21 June 2017.