Horn Book Review of Grandmother's Pigeon
“As it turned out, Grandmother was a far more mysterious woman than any of us knew,” begins this enigmatic and enjoyable picture book by Erdrich (The Birchbark House, rev. 5/99, and sequels), first published in 1996. With a page-turn, the grandmother is now shown in a motion-filled, sea-set spread, sailing away on the back of a porpoise. A year passes without Grandmother, and while the family members are going through her things, they find her birds’ nest collection. In one lies three eggs; the birds hatch and are identified as passenger pigeons — an extinct species. This leads to many questions — where did the creatures come from? where should they go? — but Grandmother’s grandchildren know what to do. Realistic-looking illustrations ground the story in naturalism, while inventive — and unexplained — details allow the inquisitive young people, with their ever-changing facial expressions, to honor their grandmother’s wishes.
Review at The Horn Book Magazine.